Live Shows: Modest Mouse and Built to Spill, MGM Music Hall at Fenway, Boston, MA 10/15/25


Modest Mouse touring with Built to Spill is a tour that would have been a dream come true for me in college, and now over two decades later, it's still a dream line up. Of course, if I had gone to see this tour in the 90's, it would have been in a much smaller venue than MGM Music Hall at Fenway. 

I'm not sure if it was advertised as such, but I had no idea that Modest Mouse was performing The Moon & Antartica in full on this tour. It was a pleasant surprise, and explains the setlist. (I can't be the only one considering how many people were yelling out requests for the entire show._ The beginning of that album can't be beat, with the opening song "3rd Planet" being a personal favorite, "Dark Center of the Universe" being a classic at this point, and "Twin Cities Made of Ash" working the crowd into a dancing frenzy. In 2025, Modest Mouse might be the most underrated live band in music today, with frontman Isaac Brock working himself into a frenzy during songs and having more energy during their two hour set than many other musicians half his age. 

After an extended playing of the theme from Jaws, Modest Mouse came back for a five song encore. Notably, "Float On" was not included, which must have been a shock for the casual fans. But, full album shows are more for the diehards, to hear albums they love and songs they never thought they'd see performed live. I'm sure the person who kept yelling out for "Missed the Boat" was disappointed.

A side note: I was shocked at how young the crowd skewed. While there were some in attendance who must have been in college when The Lonesome Crowded West or Good News for People Who Love Bad News were released, most of the crowd seemed to be in college now, or freshly out of college.

Openers Built to Spill were excellent as always. While there were some people there that were already fans, it seemed that most in attendance were unfamiliar with the indie rock legends, and also confused by someone tuning their guitar on stage. They were won over more and more as their set went on, with the applause growing with each song. By the end, they were met with a raucous reaction, and disappointment that their time was over. Three of the last four songs were "I Would Hurt a Fly," "Big Dipper," and "The Plan," and I invite any music fan to not be won over by those songs, or Doug Martsch's epic guitar playing.

On Repeat...

The New Limits - "Normal Day"

The Beths - "Mother, Pray for Me"

Brennen Leigh - "Dumpster Diving"