Live Shows: Rilo Kiley and Natalie Bergman, The Pines Theater, Northampton, MA 9/1/25
Reunion shows can be a dicey proposition. Sure, I want to hear the songs of my youth I never thought I'd be able to see live as much as everyone else, but I've also been to plenty of reunion shows that were obvious cash grabs, with a disinterested band barely acknowledging each other and waiting to get off the stage as soon as possible. However, I adore Rilo Kiley and never got to see them perform live before they disbanded in 2014, so when they announced a date in Boston at MGM Grand at Fenway, I instantly bought a ticket. When they later announced a show a week earlier at Pines Theater in Northampton, I wanted to go to both, but I've been bitten by the two reunion shows bug before and regretted it, not being able to justify the expense. A few days before, I found a reseller ticket for ridiculously cheap, so suddenly I was going to two Rilo Kiley shows in one week!
After seeing Monday night's show at Pines Theater, I can say that Rilo Kiley seem to have reunited for all the right reasons. I mean, I'm sure the money doesn't hurt, but all four members seemed to be having fun on stage. They played a set of seventeen killer songs that made every die hard fan happy. (Although, from my perspective, everyone in attendance seemed to be a die hard fan!) It was a set filled with joy and fun and nostalgia for some of the best songs of the early 00's.
And what amazing songs Rilo Kiley have. Opening with "The Execution of All Things," the band cycled through a set that included favorites like "It's a Hit," "Silver Lining," "A Better Son/Daughter," and more. Even the more emotional songs were a blast live, with Jenny Lewis displaying her acting chops while singing "Does He Love You?" and "With Arms Outstretched." With the collection of songs that Rilo Kiley has, there were simply no misses and no bathroom break songs.
Of course "Portions for Foxes" was played to a great ovation, which is understandable since, like all of Rilo Kiley's songs, it seems to get better with each and every listen. It was used to close out the main set, which could have given some of the crowd a chance to beat the traffic and head out early, which I don't think anyone did. I didn't think they could follow "Portions for Foxes," but they did with a triple shot of "Always," "More Adventurous," and "Pictures of Success." Even if it ends up being the same set, I can't wait for Sunday night in Boston.
Natalie Bergman had the tough job of opening for Rilo Kiley. Sunday night's crowd was filled with people who were there for the hits they grew up with and weren't looking for anything new. Bergman was up to the task and played a solid set of singer-songwriter tracks that won over more than a few fans. Her secret seemed to be to not pander or try to win over the crowd, but to treat Pines Theater as any other show. It may have taken a few songs, but the audience slowly started to pay more attention with every note, and were invested in Bergman by the end of her set.